Virtual private networks are sold as a universal privacy fix, but their real value is narrower and more situational. A VPN creates an encrypted tunnel between your device and a remote server, then routes your traffic out through that server’s IP address. That means your internet provider and the owner of the Wi-Fi network stop seeing which services you connect to, and the websites you visit stop seeing your real IP. What a VPN does not do is equally important: it does not make you anonymous, it does not stop phishing, and if it is free, it can become the problem itself.
- Limited but real use cases: VPNs make sense on untrusted Wi-Fi, for remote work against a corporate network, and when you want to keep your carrier from seeing which services you use.
- No anonymity guarantee: Cookies, browser fingerprinting, and logged-in accounts still identify you. A VPN only shifts who can see your traffic.
- Free services carry risk: Many free VPNs monetize by collecting and selling user data, use weak protocols, or bundle invasive advertising.
- Legal in Spain, but under pressure: Using a VPN is not prohibited, yet courts have begun issuing blocking orders against VPN providers rather than their users.
What a VPN does and what it does not
Spain’s national cybersecurity institute, INCIBE, defines a VPN as a tool that creates an encrypted connection between your device and a remote server, and recommends it for public Wi-Fi and remote work in its October 2025 guide on free and paid VPNs. The Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF), a US digital rights foundation, adds the nuance that almost nobody mentions in its digital self-defense guide, revised in July 2026: with a VPN you do not eliminate who can see your traffic, you only change who that is.
The tunnel encrypts your traffic up to the provider’s server, and from there it exits to the internet with that server’s IP address. Your carrier and the Wi-Fi owner stop seeing what you connect to; the website you visit stops seeing your real IP. But the EFF is blunt: a VPN is not an anonymity tool. Cookies and browser fingerprinting keep working, and if you log in to Google or Instagram, they know who you are with or without a tunnel.
Everything your carrier used to see is now visible to the VPN provider. The EFF warns that an unreliable service can exploit this deliberately to collect data, and notes that VPN providers also receive requests from authorities. And a VPN does not replace the basics: the same guide puts strong passwords, two-factor authentication, and updates ahead of it. If you click a fake link, the VPN will simply carry you encrypted to the scammer’s website.
When it is worth it and when it is money wasted
A VPN makes sense on hotel, airport, or café Wi-Fi, where you do not know who administers the network. It also makes sense for remote work, when your company gives you its own VPN to access its systems: there it is not optional, it is the door.
One data point changes the equation. According to the EFF, most web traffic is already encrypted with HTTPS, so protecting content on public Wi-Fi is “no longer as necessary for everyone” as it was a few years ago. HTTPS protects what you send, but not the metadata: anyone monitoring the network still sees which domains you connect to and when. That is what a VPN covers.
Streaming is another area where expectations often exceed reality. Netflix explains in its help center that with an active VPN it may only show titles with worldwide streaming rights, and that live content and the ad-supported plan do not work through a VPN. For cross-border shopping, it is worth understanding how geoblocking works in other EU online stores and when retailers can treat you differently for buying from Spain.
Our reading: for most people, a VPN is a travel and work tool, not something that needs to be on 24 hours a day. What truly protects your conversations is another layer, end-to-end encryption and what it does not cover.
Why free VPNs deserve suspicion
Someone pays for the servers, and if it is not you, it is usually your data. INCIBE notes that many free VPNs monetize the service by collecting and selling user data to third parties, that some use weak or outdated encryption protocols, and that they rely on invasive advertising. The EFF puts it in one sentence: some VPNs can be completely free but sell your data.
The most cited study on the subject is old but illustrates the risk well. In research released in January 2017, Australia’s national science agency CSIRO analyzed 283 VPN apps on Google Play: more than 38% contained some form of malware according to VirusTotal, 18% used unencrypted tunnels, and 75% included third-party tracking libraries. The market has changed since then; the business logic has not.
If you are going to use one, INCIBE recommends checking four things:
- That it has a no-logs policy for your activity, and that you can actually read it.
- That it uses current protocols: OpenVPN, IKEv2/IPsec, or WireGuard. The EFF advises against broken ones such as PPTP.
- That its privacy policy states what it does with your data.
- That it works on all your devices.
Be careful with VPNs installed as browser add-ons, too; it is worth knowing how to review extension permissions and detect a malicious or sold one.
Is using a VPN legal in Spain? The LaLiga standoff
Using a VPN is not prohibited: INCIBE itself recommends it for public Wi-Fi and remote work. What is new is that judges have begun directing blocking orders at VPN providers, not at their users.
On February 17, 2026, LaLiga announced in a press release that the Commercial Court number 1 of Córdoba had granted it preliminary injunctions, without hearing the defendants beforehand, against NordVPN and ProtonVPN. The orders require them to block access from Spain to IP addresses where LaLiga and Telefónica Audiovisual Digital detect illegal broadcasts of matches, on a dynamic basis. According to the release, the ruling could not be appealed. The same release argues that the orders treat VPN providers as intermediaries subject to the European Digital Services Regulation, a point also reported by other outlets.
May brought the first nuance. According to reporting based on a NordVPN statement, the Córdoba court refused to impose coercive fines on NordVPN, considering there was a “genuine technical dispute”: the company argued that IP addresses change within hours and that many are shared, so blocking them affects legal websites. LaLiga responded that the measures remain in force, and the main lawsuit continues.
A VPN does not make an illegitimate broadcast legitimate: it only changes the path it takes.
In our view, both sides are framing the underlying debate poorly. A VPN is neither a piracy tool nor a magic shield; it is one more intermediary to which you hand your traffic. If you need one, pay for a service with current protocols and a policy you can read. If you do not need one, which is the most common case at home, spend that time enabling two-factor authentication instead. It will protect you from more things.