GPS watches for children are marketed as a gentle stepping stone to a first smartphone: a wrist-worn device that places calls to approved contacts, sends an SOS alert and lets parents see where their child is. But security researchers and regulators have spent nearly a decade documenting what happens when these gadgets are treated as toys rather than what they really are — connected devices that continuously log the whereabouts of a minor.
- Core risk: The danger is rarely the GPS chip itself but the companion app and the servers that store a child’s location history.
- Regulatory red line: Germany banned children’s watches with a remote-listening function in 2017, and the country’s telecom regulator reaffirmed the principle in 2024.
- New EU rules: Since 1 August 2025, wearable radio equipment that processes personal or location data must include privacy protections to be sold in the EU.
- Recent testing: In 2025, Swiss firm Compass Security examined eleven children’s watches for communications flaws and eight failed.
A decade of documented failures
The landmark study came from the Norwegian Consumer Council on 18 October 2017, carried out with security company Mnemonic. Researchers analysed four models sold in Norway and found that, in a handful of steps, a stranger could take control of a watch to locate, listen to and communicate with the child, or make it appear the child was somewhere else. Some data was transmitted and stored unencrypted. The SOS button on one model and the authorised-number list on another were poorly implemented, and safe-zone exit alerts proved unreliable. Some apps lacked terms of use entirely and offered no way to delete data or an account. Manufacturers later said they had fixed some of the flaws.
A month later came the harshest response. In November 2017, Germany’s telecom regulator, the Bundesnetzagentur, banned the sale of children’s watches with a listening function, classified them as unauthorised transmitters and urged parents to destroy devices they already owned. The feature let an app trigger a call from the watch without the child noticing, transmitting nearby conversation. The regulator’s president said its investigations suggested some parents were using the devices to eavesdrop on teachers in class.
That stance has not softened. In November 2024, the Bundesnetzagentur reiterated that everyday products which record sound or images without people noticing and relay them over Wi-Fi or Bluetooth are prohibited in Germany.
The problem is not historical. In 2025, Compass Security tested eleven children’s watches for consumer magazine K-Tipp and eight failed on communications security. The full K-Tipp article sits behind a paywall and the security firm’s note does not name models or specific flaws, but the ratio suggests the issue persists.
What European law now demands
Since 1 August 2025, wrist-worn radio equipment, radio-enabled toys and child-care devices that process personal or location data must build in data-protection and privacy safeguards to be sold in the EU. The requirement stems from Delegated Regulation (EU) 2022/30, whose application date was pushed back to that point by Delegated Regulation 2023/2444.
The text itself spells out the concern. It explicitly cites devices “in the form of a wristwatch” and worries about their ability to record photos, video, location data, heart rate or sleep habits. It offers as a risk example access to settings via a default password when the connection is unencrypted or authentication is weak. It adds that such devices, when worn or aimed at children, pose risks even without an internet connection, because data can be intercepted from the radio transmission.
The next layer is the Cyber Resilience Act, which according to its Official Journal text applies generally from 11 December 2027, with obligations to report exploited vulnerabilities and incidents from 11 September 2026.
The practical gap is that many of these watches are bought on marketplaces from sellers nobody supervises, where the law helps little if the buyer does not know what to demand.
A pre-purchase checklist
Drawing on the documented failures, a short list of checks:
- Reject any watch advertising remote listening, a “voice monitor” or silent calling. That is precisely what Germany banned, and it turns the child into a microphone rather than protecting them.
- Read the app’s privacy policy before buying, as the German regulator advises. Check where data is stored, for how long, and whether you can delete the account and history. The Norwegian study found apps that did not allow it.
- Change the factory password or PIN and secure the app account with a strong one. This is the very door the European legislator cites as a risk example.
- Enable the authorised-contacts list and verify it works by calling from a number that is not on it.
- Test SOS and safe zones before trusting them; in 2017 these were exactly the functions that failed.
- Consider whether you need a camera. Consumer groups warn it may be banned in some schools and can compromise other children’s privacy.
- Ask about updates: a device that never receives them will carry its flaws forever.
It is also worth comparing alternatives. If a child already has a smartphone, sharing location through the phone’s own system may be enough. And the location of a minor is as sensitive as their photographs, so the same principles that apply to posting children’s images online apply here.
A GPS watch can give a primary-school child some autonomy and a family some peace of mind. But the right question is not how many features it packs — it is who else can see what the watch knows. If the manufacturer cannot explain that clearly in its privacy policy, that silence is already the answer.