Italy’s €805M Meta Fine Exposes the ‘One Permission’ Consent Loophole

Italy’s data protection authority has handed Meta a €805 million penalty for the way Facebook on Android accessed photos, videos and their metadata stored on users’ phones. The Garante’s decision, announced on 14 November 2026, covers roughly 20 million Android users in Italy and targets a gallery-suggestion feature that has been live since 2023. The sum works out to about 0.47% of Meta’s global revenue, but the money is arguably the least interesting part of the ruling.

  • The charge: Facebook bundled gallery access into a single, app-wide permission prompt, so users could not tell they were also switching on photo and video suggestions.
  • The legal twist: The Garante acted under Italy’s ePrivacy rules rather than the GDPR, sidestepping Ireland’s role as Meta’s EU lead regulator.
  • The remedy: Meta has 60 days to request separate, specific consent and keep the feature off by default, including for people who already granted access.

How a generic prompt became a privacy violation

The feature, labelled “Get gallery suggestions while you browse Facebook,” proposes images and clips from the phone’s local library as ideas for posts. According to the regulator, the app requested gallery access through one permission valid for the entire platform and for several functions with different purposes. Before that prompt appeared, users saw a vague notice about “enabling other functions” that never made clear the gallery suggestions were part of the deal. The option also shipped enabled by default.

The Garante stressed that a blanket permission lets the app read the phone’s entire photo archive, usually on a permanent basis, without users or the authority being able to verify what is actually used. The investigation began in July 2025 after a complaint from the Centro de Protección de Consumidores y Usuarios de Bolzano and relied on a technical analysis by the regulator itself.

The legal basis was Article 122 of the Italian Privacy Code, which transposes the EU’s ePrivacy directive and treats the phone as part of a person’s private sphere. Any access to data stored on the device requires free and informed consent, the regulator argued, regardless of whether data is transmitted or concrete harm is proven. That framing puts the user’s individual choice at the centre, even when the processing happens on-device.

Why Ireland’s shield did not hold

Meta objected that the case belonged to Ireland, home to its European subsidiary and the usual lead authority for cross-border GDPR matters. The Garante rejected that argument because ePrivacy rules have no equivalent one-stop-shop mechanism, meaning a national regulator can sanction on its own. The distinction matters: this was not an Irish GDPR decision but an Italian action grounded in national privacy law and the ePrivacy regime.

When setting the amount, the authority weighed the number of affected users, the duration of the infringement, a previous 2019 decision against Meta and what it described as poor cooperation during the investigation. The only mitigating factor was the changes Meta made after the complaint, which the regulator called late and limited to users who update the app. The infringement remains live for anyone who has not updated.

The Garante ordered Meta to request a separate, specific consent for the feature, explain what it is for, what gallery access implies and how to turn it off.

Beyond the fine, Meta must keep the tool disabled by default within 60 days, even for users who previously granted access. It must report within 30 days which measures it has started and within 90 days which it has implemented. If the deadline passes without compliance, the feature cannot be activated for anyone lacking valid consent.

The AI question left open

The Garante specified that this case did not examine whether gallery content was used to train artificial intelligence systems, an allegation Meta denies. The authority reserved the right to open separate investigations into a newer 2026 feature that processes gallery files in the cloud. That caveat keeps a second front open for Meta in Italy.

For context, the penalty sits close to the €825 million the Netherlands imposed on Uber and below the €1.2 billion Meta received over data transfers under the GDPR. Meta is expected to appeal.

The broader signal is structural. For years, large platforms have relied on Ireland’s slow-moving regulator to shield their European practices. Italy has now shown that ePrivacy offers a national route around that mechanism for anything touching the user’s device. The underlying issue is design, not a one-off bug: asking for a single broad yes to unlock a dozen distinct uses is an industry norm, and this ruling begins to dismantle it. Every app that ever bundled gallery access into a generic prompt now has a reason to re-examine how it asked.

Sources & References